Showing posts with label Kritiks. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Kritiks. Show all posts

Friday, January 23, 2009

Round 1 BF: Grapevine v. Vestavia

Aff: Grapevine

RFD: Case outweighs capitalism.

The 2NR really stakes this round on the quality of your ethics evidence and analysis. Absent a strong ethics argument, it’s a very clear affirmative ballot, as the negative concedes the truth of multiple scenarios for extinction. Asteroids is one of several, but it’s the clearest example of something that’s just not particularly susceptible to any sort of social constructionist analysis; the aff claims to stop an empirically verifiable extinction level event that doesn’t much care about our justice concerns.

Ethics remains poorly developed, however; the negative relies on repeated assertions instead of the detailed macro explanation that they desperately need. I need a really good reason to reject the plan in the face of extinction. The Zizek 4 and Zizek and Daly 4 cards don’t get you there; they posit ethical problems with capitalism. They also posit some ways that capitalism tends to misrepresent markets as neutral when instead they tend toward social exclusion. These authors would really need to advocate a strong rule-based, or deontological, morality to justify a negative ballot that recklessly disregards the primacy of survival.

Were I to attempt to justify a negative ballot, I guess I’d have to resort to the idea that ethics transforms the role of the ballot; perhaps I should consider the ballot an expression of my ethical alignment with a particular system instead of an examination of the consequences of enacting a particular policy. I can’t interject such an argument, however. The 2NR never says that, and the affirmative consistently extends their conceded framework arguments.

2NR comparative risk analysis can’t put the negative over the top without a decisive win on the nexus question of deontology. Your discussion of risk suffers from two macro problems. First, it isn’t actually a comparison; you recite some features of your critique’s risk without actually placing these factoids in the context of the affirmative advantages. You don’t say why the K’s better – you just say why you think it’s pretty nice. Secondly, it’s scripted, so any existing nuance is blurred by incomprehensible delivery.

On the micro level, the aff’s ahead on risk because they win several uncontested scenarios while at least contesting both alternative solvency (Rorty) and impact uniqueness (Eichenwald). The 2NR is long on ethics reiteration but short on any detailed explanation of how the alternative actually transitions away from capitalism.

1ac: Good pacing and delivery. I really appreciate the way in which you segment the cards by pausing slightly between them – you are very easy to flow and understand.

I don’t understand the internal link to asteroids at all. I understand that the air force has operational authority over preventing collisions, but how does the strength of the air force really affect an interception? There may well be an internal link story here, but I don’t think that’s transparent based on the tag or text of the evidence.

1nc: Good delivery, but I think there are some conceptual problems here.

As a general rule, I feel that running a single T violation contributes to T’s viability as a 2NR option. Multiple violations create too many possibilities for entirely justifiable 1AR cross-applications.

Capitalism contradicts many of your other arguments. Spiking food prices are likely a product of a market economy, not simply diversion to corn ethanol. Maintaining civil military relations to preserve stability would certainly only be a priority to fans of the current distribution of military and economic power.

I rarely vote aff on conditionality, but I’m increasingly willing to vote aff on “contradictions bad”. If the negative could hypothetically concede link turns on a disad in order to reinforce their links to the criticism, I think the neg’s creating a fairly unusual strategy skew. Also, while negative strategies should not, perhaps, be single seamless advocacy statements, there seems to be some education value to upholding some minimal standard of coherence. Almost any logical system starts with the principle of non-contradiction.

This advice applies more to Grapevine than Vestavia. I’m flexible enough that your 1NC is certainly an option, but Grapevine should make a theory argument that’s slightly more nuanced than either conditionality or conditional PICs bad.

I don’t think your politics disad makes sense. Why does Obama’s political capital affect his policies on Gaza or Israel? Doesn’t he make those diplomatic decisions free from Congressional oversight or control? Perhaps I misunderstand the disad since it’s not discussed much past the 1NC.

1NC CX: Farhad, I appreciate your graciousness on principle – you consistently describe your opponent’s RFDarguments as fair or sensical. I think you’re giving away too much perceptually, however. It’s good to be polite, but you still want to prove that their arguments are bad.

2ac:
Good overall. I think you’re weak on the counterplan. You might want to flush out the theory on the perms more thoroughly, make more defensive arguments about the net benefit, and at least start to resolve the potentially dispositive questions of PRESUMPTION and MARGIN OF ERROR. I think it’s likely that they could win a non-zero risk of this net benefit, despite some obvious flaws in their net benefit. The round might then revolve around the following nexus questions:
1. When is a fractional risk equivalent to zero risk?
2. If there’s no net benefit to the CP but it solves the aff, who wins?

2NC: These scripted overviews are way too long. They largely reiterate the position. You are too overview dependent and need to clash more directly with their responses.

Ethics is a great example of this – it’s eventually the real nexus question, but I don’t have any useful information other than a couple of cards and an explanation of past future present present past that would be difficult to filter and absorb at 100 WPM, let alone 250.

2NC C-x:

You ask the 2NC, essentially, if he dropped asteroids (he did) and if his ethics explanation made any sense (not really.) Accurate diagnosis of neg flaws, but those are genuinely the worst possible CX question in this scenario, because there’s a 1NR. He could hypothetically instruct her to shore up these weaknesses.

NEVER EVER give them a chance to make up for their errors (did you drop asteroids)

NEVER just give them a chance to explain where they are crucially weak (ethics)

Undermine them CONCEPTUALLY instead of going after TECHNICAL WEAKNESS, because there’s a 1NR.

Thursday, January 22, 2009

Hooch v. Milton Round 6 Pace RR

Negative: Milton

RFD: I expected to vote affirmative after the 1AR and after the 2NR. Chattahoochee was, in my mind, soundly beating Milton on the core questions of this debate. Regardless of various consideration of frameworks, my ballot’s going to reflect my judgment on whether I should endorse massive federal funding of SPS or reject space exploration entirely through individual instances of power. The 1AR, in my mind, successfully defended the affirmative’s method of empiricism as a means of truth seeking. Even if the aff leads to objectionable political effects, I would still feel compelled to vote for them if their 1AC claims and/or addon advantages are true. Case supercedes the criticism. Alternately, if the negative claims about the aff’s irrelevance or untruth are true, I’m probably voting for them. Until the last rebuttals, I feel the aff’s grappling with these core questions far more effectively than the negative.

Unfortunately for Chattahoochee, the 2AR shifts focus from these questions into a less relevant discussion of fiat and framework. I’m not compelled by these questions in either direction in this instance. The negative has conceded that the affirmative’s able to claim their impacts – they aren’t theoretically precluded from advocating for the truth of these advantages. Conversely, the negative’s objection isn’t theoretically precluded either – if they impact turn the affirmative, they moot questions of the alternative’s theoretical legitimacy. Opening with a rousing defense of speed and policy debate thus seems largely non sequitur.

On a micro level, the affirmative simply drops a number of devastating (albeit spurious) negative claims. The 2AR never explicitly answers “all of your evidence is lies because it’s fabricated to prop up a certain system of power relations.” The 2AR also doesn’t answer the racialization of science, which taints the way you derive your conclusions. The 2AR doesn’t answer the claim that considerations of race are a prior decision rule. The aff claims about empiricism might implicitly answer this, but the affirmative neither teases out the relationship between the two sets of claims nor develops their empiricism and science claims beyond the barest and most elliptic assertions.

Chattahoochee does not need much to beat this. I don’t mind embedded clash – but there’s too much embedding and not enough actual clash. 3-4 sentences starting with “empiricism trumps their claims of bias because..” would probably reverse my decision.

The affirmative also suffers from some related problems because of the quality of their evidence. I think their evidence may well have made some impressive arguments before it went under the knife, but Chattahoochee most definitely cuts away muscle as well as fat. These cards verge on incoherence. Here’s a sample sentence from your Jarvis evidence: “Revisionism…be unconnected to the world postmodernists.” Really? That be pretty good. I don’t drop the affirmative out of exasperation, but this does hurt you. Strength of evidence might redeem the 2AR’s analytic gaps, but it can’t when you generally have a claim at best. Paragraph length explanations can compensate for bad evidence. Good evidence can compensate for sketchy extension. If there’s not much story and word salad cards, however, it’s difficult to assemble an affirmative ballot.

This problem haunts Rawls and Jarvis; I don’t really see where the aff’s going with these cards. Your intent might be clearer if you read more of the evidence in the form of complete sentences. Nansen [sp?] doesn’t address the core question of methodology. Taft-Kaufman is definitely the closest, and it’s warranted. The absence of spin prevents this card from being dispositive, however. Specifically, it says I should prefer an emphasis on material problems and solutions to purely discursive considerations. That’s a fair point, and might push me to prefer the aff to the alternative, all other things being equal. They aren’t, though. An effective material solution’s preferable, but Taft-Kaufman can’t convince me that the aff is that effective solution. The argument presumes the advantages as a premise, but the negative’s undermined that. Put simply, you aren’t effective if your impacts are all bad racist lies. Discourse is worse than a good plan, but the neg proved your plan’s advantages are dirty dirty lies, so it’s probably better than that.

I can discuss line by line questions with that – that governing framework really determines the resolution of any remaining questions. The aff’s a lie, and it distracts from more important questions of racial and economic justice. My natural inclination is that the aff’s a survival question, which outweighs, and their add-ons turn the K, but you need to dispense of the prior question of methodology with some more substantive analysis to get there.

1ac:

Your highlighting is suboptimal. I frequently hear sets of noun phrases unconnected by verbs. For future reference, I’m violently opposed to the sacrificing coherence for the sake of brevity; I often disregard cards entirely if they’re splattered with the blood of the English language.

You need to pause between cards, for under .35s, but for enough of an interval to distinguish between claims and pieces of evidence. Your delivery isn’t exactly passionate – I’m fine with that, but your bland neutrality really makes it necessary that you use some technique to delineate between your robot word sets.

When you say “PUT YOUR DAS AWAY” – people laugh at you. That can be good or bad, depending on your perspective on comedy. Personally, I’m a fan, but I want to make sure I’m laughing with you, not at you.

1NC:

1. Your tech breaks, hahaha. So much for your song now! You should definitely have a test run.
2. I’m not a big fan of this performance. You aren’t performing it. We’re all just watching your laptop, reduced to passive spectators. Recorded performance always seems antithetical to debate. Sampling is cool – I’m a fan of tech that enhances expression, but not a fan of tech that substitutes for expression entirely. Short samples = good, long samples where we all stare awkwardly at a machine = meh.

I mean, I’m not sure how I’d really filter this competitively, either. I generally feel that art exists, in part, to express something that can’t be expressed more efficiently in straightforward expository discourse. A poem that restated the politics disad in rhyme wouldn’t serve much purpose, aside from satire or irony.

What does this performance really say that couldn’t be said in three minutes with some cards?

2AC:

Sometimes you are incomprehensible. Most of the time you are clear. 2ACs against a one-off K should do more than read. They should adapt their responses a bit. For example, you argue that the alternative’s vague enough to merit a negative ballot without a saying a word about their alternative. Moments like this make it more difficult for you to respin your answer toward their specific argument later on.

1AR:
Very good. I like the parts about empiricism – relationship between the neg and truth claims is pretty good to highlight.

2NR:
Loses some focus due to time pressure; I think that you’re probably better on an explanatory level in the 2NC, but this breaks down some here. I view this as a structural problem with the position more than a failure in execution. You have a narrow 1Nc that puts very little pressure on the 2AC, because it really only says a few things. In this circumstance, the 2NR is The Reckoning. You’d have to be very good on performativity rendering their straightforward truth claims irrelevant to justify setting yourself up like this. You aren’t – you largely sag away from those claims – so you probably wish your 1AC was different in some ways.

2AR:
RFD.

Wednesday, December 3, 2008

East Lansing FL v. Stratford FM, Round 7 GBN

1AC:
--Your vocal pattern follows a very predictable pattern that's both determinate and completely divorced from every meaning. I'd call it an "intonation template" or, perhaps more accurately, a Procrustean bed. Abandon that template. Intonation conveys meaning, whereas a robotic template's entirely self-referential. Debate, ideally, is just like normal speech intonation-wise, albeit exaggerated and much much faster.

--You need slight pauses between different contentions and cards. These small vocal bookends really aid comprehension.

1AC CX:
1A - When he questions a card, don't just abandon it. You immediately cede his arguments and bring in new cards, fleeing the perceptual high ground.
2N - You're very efficient in the CX. That helps. Your transitions and section introductions ("now let's talk about [issue x]) are probably unnecessarily verbose, though.

1NC:
I'm not a big fan of Heidegger, because I don't think it really disproves the aff's truth value - it exposes a philosophical assumption, but not a premise of their internal link chain.

Capitalism is probably more relevant. I appreciate that you read an impact framing card - I'd prefer that Mezeros [sp?] card that provides a reason to reject short-term crises in favor of structural analysis. I always find that very helpful for resolving cap debates (when I'm voting negative.)

Stylistically, you should probably just get faster - try this. (Be sure to go to advanced settings and check "variability".)

You should also try to avoid rising intonation? because it makes all your statements? sounds like questions? (I do realize that the wiki labels my conception as a 'misconception' here, but I think I'm accurately describing the rhetorical effect in a debate round, even if a linguist would disagree with my broader point.)

2AC:

1. Near incomprehensible in sections. You have to mark your cards better - you hand over a card with ~15 different marks but actually read the shortest version. It seems quite unfair to not tell the negative which mark you used, when you'd presumably volunteer that information to me readily if I decide to scrutinize your materials.

2. Your framework arguments seem redundant at points - you spend a great deal of time objecting to the legitimacy of their argument, and very little time answering it. You need to spend more time answering their argument and, probably, defending the case.

2NC:

Very good on T.

You need some clearer explanations of your method on Heidegger - or why your method either precludes a consideration of the aff or disproves their conclusion. I often have trouble answering this question when I'm trying to construct a negative K ballot:

"Yeah, maybe our method's associated with some real bad stuff politically, but how does that mean it's wrong-incorrect as well as wrong-bad?"

1NR:

Good job. You should be go faster and read some more evidence. I appreciate your devotion to comprehensibility and on point clash - I just think it's a narrow 1NR and they didn't say much - you should be reading 20-25 cards minimum in this speech.

1AR:
1. Extend the case impacts they DON'T answer.

2. Your T coverage leaves something to be desired. It's about 10 seconds. I think you should have adhered to the classic structure where you cover it on top to make sure you don't drop it. You could only justify this allocation against a violation that was obviously factually incorrect.

Partner communication - 2A - the 1AR asks if he should move on. It's disturbing that he feels compelled to ask - and doubly disturbing that you say "no."

2NR:

There aren't many ways you can lose. Still, there are some doors you should probably close.

a. Pre-empt new 2AR - you should talk, briefly, about the standard of strict scrutiny I should employ when I try to match the 2ar to the 1ar.

b. Theory on the K - I think they jettisoned all of this. It's their best shot, though, so you might want to paragraph about why T is the most important theoretical impact to cover your bases.

Arbitrariality - word or no? I think not - I think it's arbitrariness.

2AR:

1. Check back is not a real phrase. Check means the same thing.
2. You have to tie your 2AR carefully to the 1AR and probably pre-empt newness. (this will be the majority of the postround explanation.)

Hunt desperately for some theory you can revive on the K - it may be your only shot.

RFD:

Time allocation problems force the 1AR to spend about 10 seconds extending three labels. The 2NR really only needs to meet a very minimal burden of extension, as the block already answered the 2AC - the 1AR does nothing to advance the debate. In the absence of some genuinely compelling and incontrovertible fact, my vote's compelled.

A creative 2AR might have revolved around extending and weighing dropped turns on the K, although I doubt I would have allowed it.